It’s a win-win for Prospect Harbor. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) has offered to help fund the restoration of the beloved Big Jim statue—if he swaps his sardine can for a block of tofu, giving the landmark a compassionate, modern update.

Fish are intelligent, complex individuals. Studies show they are capable of learning, building, and communicating. They have long memories, sing to each other, share knowledge, and have cultural traditions. Some fish woo their potential partners by singing to them. Some fish can recognize themselves in a mirror, and others woo potential partners by creating intricate works of art in the sand on the ocean floor. And like the dogs and cats who share our homes, they feel pain and fear. When they’re dragged from the ocean, suffocated, and cut open, they suffer immensely.

Trading sardines for soy wouldn’t erase tradition—it would reflect a sea of change in how we view the animals around us. Just as New England has moved beyond whaling while still honoring its maritime heritage, communities today can celebrate their history while embracing kindness.

A reimagined Big Jim could spark conversation, draw visitors, and stand tall for all living beings. That’s an upgrade worth making waves about.

Kate Swigart lives in Hampden and is a member of PETA