132 Organizations Sign Statement on Government Coronavirus Emergency Transparency and Public Access

Ensure the public’s business remains transparent and accessible during COVID-19 emergency

Open government is not ‘bureaucratic red tape’
Tue, 03/24/2020 - 9:45am

    The Maine Press Association, along with the Maine Broadcasters Association and the Maine Freedom of Information Coalition, have joined other trade, academic and civil liberty organizations around the country in signing and sending a joint statement to state and national governmental groups that emphasizes the right to government emergency transparency and public access.

    The letter grew from the National Freedom of Information Coalition, a Florida-based nonprofit that promotes press freedom, legislative and administrative reforms and litigation to ensure open, transparent and accessible state and local governments and public institutions.

    “One hundred and thirty-two (132) organizations representing diverse constituencies and political ideologies agree that our democracy and democratic practices should not be obstructed in the interest of streamlining deliberations and decision making by our governing bodies in this time of crisis,” the NFOIC said.

    The letter follows:

    As state, tribal and local governments across the United States take measures to respond to the COVID-19 epidemic, executive orders and legislative proposals are calling for the suspension of normal operating procedures including, at times, compliance with open-meeting and public-records laws.

    We strongly urge government branches and agencies to recommit to, and not retrench from, their duty to include the public in the policy-making process, including policies relating to COVID-19 as well as the routine ongoing functions of governance.

    Government bodies should not opportunistically take advantage of the public’s inability to attend large gatherings to make critical decisions affecting the public’s interest if those decisions can reasonably be postponed. Just as citizens are being asked to defer nonessential travel and errands, so should government agencies defer noncritical policy-making decisions until full and meaningful public involvement can be guaranteed.

    Where postponement is not realistic, every available measure should be taken to

    (1) notify the public of meetings of government bodies and how to participate in those meetings remotely,

    (2) use widely available technologies to maximize real-time public engagement, and

    (3) preserve a viewable record of proceedings that is promptly made accessible online.

    We understand that government agencies will struggle with staffing and time constraints during this period of exigency, as employees transition into working from home, attend to personal and family health needs, and become focused on crisis-response duties.

    Some agencies undoubtedly will have difficulty meeting their legal obligations to process requests for public records promptly and thoroughly.

    This predictable difficulty counsels strongly in favor of affirmatively disclosing as much as is legally permissible without waiting to receive a request for records. Members of the press and public often resort to freedom-of-information requests when decisions are made secretively. It should not be necessary to reconstruct critical decisions about public health and safety by piecing together email trails. The fact that a government decision involves public health and safety is a reason for more, not less, transparency.

    As government employees begin transacting more public business off-premises on personal devices, it is important that they faithfully observe records-retention protocols so that messages about core governmental functions are retrievable and reviewable just as on-premises correspondence is.

    All official-business communications -- regardless of where it occurs, and whose devices and accounts are used -- should take place over channels that allow for messages to be easily archived, produced and read.

    When possible, all electronic communications and information sharing should be transacted through official email accounts and government-issued communication devices.

    At all times, but most especially during times of national crisis, trust and credibility are the government’s most precious assets. As people are asked to make increasing sacrifices in their daily lives for the greater good of public health, the legitimacy of government decision-making requires a renewed commitment to transparency.

    Open government is not “bureaucratic red tape.” We encourage the custodians of information at all levels of government to take this opportunity to leverage technology to make governance more inclusive and more credible, not to suspend compliance with core accountability imperatives in the name of expediency.

    Alabama Broadcasters Association
    American Booksellers Association
    American Oversight
    Americans for Prosperity Foundation
    Arizona Broadcasters Association
    Arizona First Amendment Coalition
    Arkansas Broadcasters Association
    Brechner Center for Freedom of Information
    Buffalo School of Law Civil Liberties and Transparency Clinic Cadiz Record (Kentucky

    California Broadcasters Association California State University Campaign for Accountability
    Cause of Action Institute

    Center for Progressive Reform
    Center for Public Integrity
    Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington
    Civil Beat Law Center for the Public Interest
    College of Communication and Information, University of Tennessee. Knoxville Colorado Broadcasters Association

    Colorado Freedom of Information Coalition Connecticut Broadcasters Association Connecticut Council on Freedom of Information Council of State Archivists

    Dawson Springs Progress (Kentucky)

    Design Access Network

    District of Columbia Open Government Coalition Electronic Frontier Foundation
    The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) Embarcadero Media Group

    Espacios Abiertos
    First Amendment Clinic Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law, Arizona State University First Amendment Coalition
    Florida First Amendment Foundation
    Florida Press Association
    FOIA Group, Inc.
    Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE)
    Franklin Favorite ​(Kentucky)
    Free Speech Coalition
    Georgia First Amendment Foundation
    Government Accountability project
    Hawaii Association of Broadcasters
    Hoptown Chronicle Newspaper (Kentucky)
    Illinois Broadcasters Association
    Indiana Coalition for Open Government

    Indiana Broadcasters Association
    Institute for Rural Journalism and Community Issues Iowa Freedom of Information Council
    Iowa Institute for Public Accountability
    Iowa Newspaper Association
    The Julian News​ (California)
    Kansas Association of Broadcasters
    Kentucky New Era
    Kentucky Open Government Coalition
    Kentucky Press Association
    Knowles Publishing Corporation
    LION Publishers
    Louisiana Association of Broadcasters
    Louisiana Press Association
    Madisonville Messenger (Kentucky​)
    Maine Association of Broadcasters
    Maine Freedom of Information Coalition
    Maine Press Association
    Maryland | Delaware | DC Press Association Massachusetts Broadcasters Association Massachusetts Newspaper Publishers Association Media Freedom Foundation Project Censored Michigan Coalition for Open Government
    Michigan Press Association

    Minnesota Broadcasters Association
    Minnesota Coalition On Government Information Missouri Broadcasters Association
    Missouri Press Association
    Montana Broadcasters Association
    National Association of Black Journalists National Association of Hispanic Journalist
    New England First Amendment Coalition
    North Carolina Open Government Coalition North Dakota Newspaper Association
    National Center for Health Research
    National Coalition Against Censorship
    National Freedom of Information Coalition Native American Journalists Association Nebraska Broadcasters Association
    Nebraska Press Association
    Nevada Open Government Coalition
    New Jersey Broadcasters Association
    New Mexico Broadcasters Association
    New Mexico Foundation for Open Government News Leaders Association
    North Carolina Press Association
    North Dakota Broadcasters Association
    Oak Grove Eagle Post​ (Kentucky)
    Oklahoma Association of Broadcasters

    Freedom of Information Oklahoma

    Oregon Association of Broadcasters
    PEN America
    Pennsylvania Freedom of Information Coalition Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association Providence Journal-Enterprise (Kentucky)
    Radio Television Digital News Association Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press Rhode Island Broadcasters Association Russellville News-Democrat & Leader​ (Kentucky) Sage Information Services

    Santa Monica Daily Press
    Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law, University of Minnesota Society of Professional Journalists
    Society of Professional Journalists, DC Chapter
    South Dakota Newspaper Association
    Special Libraries Association
    Student Press Law Center
    Tennessee Association of Broadcasters
    Texas Association of Broadcasters
    Texas Press Association
    Union of Concerned Scientists
    Union for Reform Judaism
    Utah Broadcasters Association

    Utah Press Association
    Vermont Association of Broadcasters
    Virginia Association of Broadcasters Washington Coalition for Open Government Washington State Association of Broadcasters West Virginia Broadcasters Association WFKN Radio​ (Kentucky)
    Wisconsin Broadcasters Assn
    Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council Wisconsin Newspaper Association
    The Wisconsin Transparency Project Wyoming Association of Broadcasters